92-XX BIOLOGY AND OTHER NATURAL SCIENCES
Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (3)
Language
- English (3) (remove)
Has Fulltext
- yes (3)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (3)
Keywords
- Monitoring (2)
- Bach Ma Nationalpark (1)
- Bicyclus anynana (1)
- Biosphärenreservate (1)
- Empirische Sozialforschung (1)
- Evaluierung (1)
- Großschutzgebiet (1)
- Information (1)
- Landsat (1)
- Landscape Metrics (1)
Institute
In holometabolic insects, senescence starts at sexual maturation and condition diminishes with age. Young virgin males should gain the highest mating success. Although sperm quality and quantity typically decreases with age, older males have been shown to have a higher mating success in a variety of insect taxa. Life-history theory predicts an increased aggressive and persistent courtship behaviour, due to a decrease of the residual reproductive value and thus, the opportunity for future reproduction. In the butterfly Bicyclus anynana, older males gain up to a 4x higher mating success despite a poorer condition, compared to younger males. As older males were found to court more often and for longer time bouts,suggesting a higher intrinsic motivation, there is evidence for the residual reproductive value hypothesis. On the other hand, an age-specific variation of male sex pheromones may provide females with information, being helpful to chose specific males. The latter could be males which have proven a high fitness in terms of survival, thus essentially reflecting a “good genes" hypothesis. This doctoral thesis investigated the reasons underlying old male mating advantage in B. anynana. The first study tested whether old male mating advantage prevails, even if females were unable to distinguish between older and younger males. The results were backed up by examining female rejection rates, male courtship frequency, courtship duration, time to copulation and mating duration. Older males had a significantly higher mating success compared to younger ones regardless of differences in pheromone blends or the females ability to smell. Older males courted more often and longer. The results support the residual reproductive value hypothesis. Study 2 investigated post-copulatory sexual selection in B. anynana. Females were double-mated, allowing for sperm competition and cryptic mate choice. Older males had a higher paternity success than younger ones, when the former were the last mating partner. The paternity success was balanced across age classes when older males were the first mating partner. Older males transferred larger spermatophores with higher numbers of eupyrene sperm than younger males. B. anynana does not exhibit cryptic mate choice and last-male precedence is the most probable fertilization pattern. The higher proportion of offspring sired by older males is due to significantly increased numbers of fertile sperm compared to younger males. The latter are clearly disadvantaged, as the higher sperm numbers provided by older males counteract the benefits of last-male precedence. Study 3 explored determinants of mating success in B. anynana. Successful males had longer wings, a heavier thorax, a lighter abdomen, a higher fat content, and higher phenoloxidase expression levels. Mating success seemed to be directly linked to proxies of flight performance. Successful males showed a better flight performance, in turn increasing mating success. As energy reserves are of crucial importance for flight manoeuvres, they may play a significant role in male mating success. Study 4 tested the effects of male age and mating number on spermatophore mass, sperm number, male oxidative status, and reproductive success by manipulating age and mating frequency in male B. anynana. Spermatophore mass and sperm numbers increased significantly with age, while antioxidant defences and oxidative damage declined. Female fecundity and egg-hatching success was highest when being mated with young virgin males. Antioxidant defences decreased with age, being a possible reason for the negatively affected reproductive success in females. Ejaculate quality diminished with age and mating number, despite larger spermatophores and higher sperm numbers being found in older males. Therefore, spermatophore size and sperm numbers can not be considered as reliable proxies of male condition. The final study proofed whether male sex pheromone comprise honest signals and which traits might be associated with increased pheromone titres. Pheromone titres were analysed among successful and unsuccessful males when being mated with either a control or a scent-blocked female. Both groups did not differ in pheromone levels. Successful males had significantly higher numbers of eupyrene sperm. No correlation between male pheromones and any investigated trait was found, suggesting that pheromone titres do not provide reliable information on male quality. Nothing indicates that male sex pheromones in B. anynana play a decisive role in female mate choice. Successful males generally have a better body condition, resulting in a more vigorous courtship behaviour and higher sperm numbers. Hence, variation in body condition rather than pheromone titres is more likely to determine male mating success. Mating decisions are primarily driven by male behaviour. The results suggest that old male mating advantage arises from sexual conflict.
All-embracing human activities have transformed one-third to one-half of the Earth’s land surface. There is a strong correlation of human well-being with ecosystem function, including poverty alleviation programs as well as enhancements of the health sector. To assess and evaluate the progress and outcome of initiatives stringent periodic observation is necessary. The presented approach combines the strengths of remote sensing and GIS analysis with social research applications. The Bach Ma National Park as an area under investigation was designated as protected area in 1991 and extended in 2008. The national park is uninhabited, but in the surrounding buffer zones approximately 62000 to 79000 people live in rural areas and in mostly impoverished conditions. The comprehensive nature conservation efforts of the Vietnamese Government during the last two decades has led to growing forest coverage of both plantation and natural forests. Nevertheless, the decreasing biodiversity and ongoing illegal logging and hunting activities in the national park are seen as major threats to conservation initiatives in the future. The remote sensing component consists of an analysis of a time series of Landsat images with seven steps ranging from 1973 to 2010. The resulting land cover analysis had 13 different classes. The accuracy assessment revealed an overall accuracy ranging from 84 to 90%. The basis for the second monitoring component was the Landsat images. A total of 25 different landscape metrics on the landscape, class, and patch level were calculated by FRAGSTATS. The third monitoring component is itself divided into two parts. This part consists of a qualitative social research study with 26 expert interviews. The second part consists of 61 standardized questionnaires and an evaluation by SPSS. The assessment reveals a more or less stable forest cover, but with a considerable degradation process during the last four decades. Urban areas outside of the national park have increased in size considerably. For dense and medium forest patches an increasing fragmentation and isolation of patches was observed. Patches of natural forests and habitats of thousands of species have declined dramatically, a trend that is related to a decreasing core area characterised by its undisturbed conditions. The Landsat images and landscape metrics reveal the major differences between the national park and surrounding areas. Despite extensive alterations near the border, remaining forest patches in the national park are still bigger and less fragmented. Nevertheless, the third monitoring component revealed undiscovered changes in the forest beyond the possibilities of used images and metrics. It includes illegal logging and hunting activities. Non-timber forest products are similar to faunistic species collected for both the subsistence of the local residents and associated markets as important sources of income. Based on this bisection, local residents as well as certain strangers are responsible for the activities in the forest. The plan of national park management is to intensify existing monitoring and patrolling in the forest to limit the exploitation and impact in relevant zones. Furthermore, the importance of a network of protected areas has attracted increasing attention. The assessment of the questionnaires reveals that deforestation and also reforestation were the key aspects of historical land cover change. Additionally, for the local residents the conversion of forests into arable land as income alternative is of major importance. Capacity development is not only one priority of the Bach Ma management but also of the international community for all of Vietnam. The tourism industry, one of the most promising opportunities of recent years, stands to support both national park management as well as the local residents. For local residents the extraction of non-timber forest products is an essential portion of the income. The current pilot policy 126/QD-TTg in the extension zone of the national park and research on an appropriate sharing mechanism is of the utmost importance. The established and presented monitoring components are cost-effective and can be used to regularly assess the land cover change of a protected area. They can be implemented together or individually into existing monitoring schemes. A smart combination of pre-existing datasets is necessary to overcome the inconsequential amount of money for monitoring procedures. Supplemented by socio-economic monitoring and the demands as well as impacts of human activity need to be integrated. These extensive requirements for prospective monitoring are only feasible with comprehensive and reliable collaborations.
Mind the gap: Information gaps and bridging options in assessing in-situ conservation achievements
(2008)
The biodiversity crisis has gained political attention on a global level. The “2010 Target” of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) aims to significantly reduce the loss of biodiversity by 2010. In order to achieve this, a network of representative and effectively managed protected areas is to be established. The effectiveness of protected areas thus represents one indicator for progress towards the CBD’s 2010 Target. However, indicators require information. The present study, in a first step, reviews the availability of open access long-term ecological data for assessing protected area effectiveness. This review shows two parallel – though contradictory – phenomena: data overkill and data scarcity. While the number of online databases providing open access data on biodiversity has grown tremendously, no long-term ecological data for a larger set of protected areas can be openly accessed. Reasons for this data scarcity are discussed. Based on this lack of information, in a second step, a method to bridge information gaps through social science research is aspired. An innovative Conservation Success Framework is developed, which defines and relates conservation needs, conservation capacity and conservation actions, its three main components. The basic assumption is that conservation can only be successful where the conservation capacity exists that is required to implement the conservation actions determined by the conservation needs. The framework was used to develop open and closed questionnaires for application in two Mexican biosphere reserves, the Sierra Gorda and the Sierra de Manantlán. As "conservation success" is often immeasurable in protected areas in practice due to unspecific conservation objectives the term is for the case studies substituted by “conservation achievements”, i.e. clearly noticeable effects from conservation actions. Overall, almost 60 interviews were conducted with different stakeholder groups. The gained information is validated through social science research techniques, such as triangulation of perspectives and active and passive observation. Based on this, conservation needs are identified and conservation capacities summarised and discussed for both case study sites. Implemented conservation actions addressing identified conservation needs and conservation capacity constraints are then analysed. In addition, noticeable effects from conservation actions on the state of biodiversity at case study sites, i.e. the conservation achievements, are described. Where locally available, non-open access data (as opposing open access data) are used to verify the findings from the social science research. Identified conservation achievements at both case study sites are evident both from quantitative information (for example forest cover increase according to non-open access data) and qualitative information (for example perceived change in the occurrence of illegal activities according to interviews). In addition, rather “intangible” indicators that can only be revealed through qualitative surveys are identified for both sites. This study thus highlights the crucial importance of integrating different types of data, ecological and socio-economic, as well as quantitative and qualitative ones. The present study concludes with a series of recommendations 1) to local practitioners at the two case study sites, and 2) to the international conservation community. Local practitioners may benefit from the present study because its results provide for each site a) an overview of existing conservation needs and implemented conservation actions; b) an easy way to identify action gaps; c) a baseline to identify progress indicators; and d) an overview of diverse perspectives on the current effectiveness of the biosphere reserves. These benefits are considered of particular importance as they can be influential in the revision of the site’s management plans, which both are now approximately ten years old and will soon be revised. The international conservation community will not be able to make a clear statement in the year 2010 about the effectiveness of protected areas on a global level due to a lack of information and transparency. However, the year 2010 should not be considered an end point for measuring progress in in-situ conservation; instead protected area quality standards must be created, effectiveness evaluations institutionalised and efforts to foster regular reporting must continue. Consequently, a scheme of consolidated actions from local to national and international level is proposed that could help to sustainably bridge existing information gaps and close them on the long run. In the end, progress reporting on the effectiveness of protected areas, and other indicators, can only improve if different governance levels “mind the information gaps” in cooperation, until continued information gathering and sharing hopefully closes these gaps one day.