Doctoral Thesis
Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (3) (remove)
Language
- English (3) (remove)
Has Fulltext
- yes (3)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (3)
Keywords
- Rotbuche (3) (remove)
Species have to cope with climate change either by migration or by adaptation and acclimatisation. Especially for long-living tree species with a low seed dispersal capacity (e.g. European beech, hereafter called beech), the in situ responses through genetic adaptation and phenotypic plasticity play an important role for their persistence. Beech, the dominant climax tree species in Central Europe, shows a high drought sensitivity and its distribution range is expected to shift northwards. On the other hand, projected northward shifts need to be taken with caution, as some studies suggest a sensitivity of beech to frost events in winter and spring. However, studies on the growth performance of cold-marginal beech populations are still rare. Previous studies on beech populations found local adaptation to drought and phenotypic plasticity in fitness-related traits as well as phenological traits. However, studies on the regeneration of beech under natural conditions are yet missing, although germination and establishment of young trees are a very first selective bottleneck and are crucial for tree population persistence and for successful range shifts.
This PhD-thesis aimed to identify the potential of plasticity and local adaptation in the important early life-history traits germination, establishment after the 1st year, and survival after the 2nd year in a reciprocal transplantation experiment at 11 sites across and even beyond the distribution range of beech (Manuscript 1). Moreover, this thesis investigated the climate sensitivity and the adaptation potential of beech populations by conducting dendroecological studies along a large climatic gradient across the distribution range (Manuscript 2) and along a strong winter temperature gradient towards the cold distribution margin in Poland (Manuscript 3). In addition, the impact of local climatic singularities was studied in a local study at the southern margin (Manuscript 4).
Warm and dry conditions limited natural regeneration, which was indicated by very low survival of young trees, even though germination rates increased with increasing temperature (Manuscript 1). This was also the case in parts of the distribution centre due to the hot and dry conditions in 2018. Although the transplantation experiment revealed high plasticity in the early life-history traits, this plasticity might thus not buffer against climate change under dry conditions. Local adaptation was not detected for any of these traits along the climatic gradient. In contrast, the results of the dendroecological study across the gradient (Manuscript 2) hint towards an adaptation potential of adult trees to drought at the southern margin. Thus, adult trees seemed to be adapted to drought at the southern margin, whereas tree growth in the distribution centre was sensitive to drought. These results indicate that parts of the centre may become ecologically marginal with increasing drought frequency in times of climate change. Interestingly, Manuscript 4 shows that beech growth was positively influenced by frequent fog immersion at the southern distribution margin in north-eastern Spain. This study underlines the importance of local climatic singularities, as they may allow marginal populations to grow in climate refugia in an otherwise unfavourable climate.
At the cold distribution margin, the study in Manuscript 1 found a remarkably higher survival of young trees in Sweden than in Poland. Moreover, the dendroecological studies revealed that beech was hampered by both drought at the cold-dry margin (Manuscript 2) and by winter cold at the cold-wet margin in Poland (Manuscript 3). All these results highlight the importance to study climate sensitivity of adult trees and the response of early life-history traits at the cold margin with a more differentiated view comparing cold-dry against the cold-wet populations and growing conditions. However, the high plasticity of the early life-history traits may allow for an increasing germination rate with climate warming at the northern margin and may thus facilitate natural regeneration there. In contrast, the dendroecological studies suggest that adult trees at the cold distribution margin may suffer either from drought or from winter cold and that the risk for spring frost may increase. Thus, the often-predicted compensation of dry-marginal population decline by a northward range expansion should be discussed more critically.
In conclusion, my PhD thesis provides new knowledge about the potential of natural regeneration and about climate sensitivity of adult trees across the distribution range of beech. Moreover, it underlines the importance to study both the young tree stages as well as adult trees to assess the performance and vulnerability of tree species under climate change, as both showed differences in their response to changing environmental conditions.
The rapid anthropogenic climate change that is projected for the 21st century is predicted to have severe impacts on ecosystems and on the provision of ecosystem services. With respect to the longevity of trees, forestry in particular has to adapt now to future climate change. This requires profound multidisciplinary knowledge on the direct and indirect climate sensitivity of forest ecosystems on various spatial scales. Predictions on growth declines due to increasing drought exposition during climate change are widely recognized for European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.), which is the major forest tree in European temperate deciduous forests. However, research from other continents or other biomes has shown that winter climate change may also affect forest growth dynamics due to declining snow cover and increased soil cooling. So far, this winter cold sensitivity is largely unexplored in Europe. Thus, particularly focussing on forest growth dynamics and winter cold sensitivity, the goal of this PhD-project was to explore how climate sensitivity of forest ecosystems differs regionally. By doing so, the project aimed to deliver insights about possibilities and limits of upscaling regional knowledge to a global understanding of climate sensitivity. To achieve these goals, this PhD-project integrated five studies (Manuscripts 1–5) that investigated the climate sensitivity of biogeochemical cycles, plant species composition in forests, and forest growth dynamics across spatial scales. In particular, a large-scale gradient-design field experiment simulated the influence of winter climate change on forest ecosystems by snow cover and soil temperature manipulations (Manuscript 1). This study indicated that soil cooling and decreased root nutrient uptake may indirectly reduce growth of adult forest trees. Moreover, this study indicated uniform ecological sensitivity to soil temperature changes across sites along a large winter temperature gradient (ΔT = 4 K across 500 km), irrespective of the site-specific history of snow cover conditions, which motivates upscaling from local winter climate change studies to the regional scale. Although regional climate drives growth of adult forest trees, local factors, such as site-specific edaphic conditions, might control plants in the forest understory. This assumption was tested by mapping the forest understory composition along the same winter temperature gradient as introduced above (Manuscript 2). Across sites, this study found that edaphic conditions explained the spatial turnover in the forest understory composition more than climate, which might moderate direct climate change impacts on the forest understory composition. However, edaphic conditions, forest structure, and climate are linked by triangular interactions. Thus, climate change might still indirectly affect the forest vegetation dynamics. Moreover, a dendroecological study focussed on the same winter temperature gradient from central to cold-marginal beech populations as above in order to identify gradual changes in summer drought and winter cold sensitivity in tree growth (Manuscript 3). Towards the cold distribution margin, the influence of drought on tree growth gradually decreased, while growth reductions were increasingly related to winter cold due to harsher winter climate. By a large-scale dendroecological network study assessed the relationship of growth dynamics to climate and reproductive effort in beech forests across Europe (Manuscript 4). Indeed, this study found the general pattern across the distribution range of beech that high temperature controlled growth indirectly via resource allocation to reproduction. However, the strong, direct drought signal that could be generally detected from dry-marginal to central populations vanished towards the cold-marginal populations, where the more focussed study of Manuscript 3 identified a stronger relationship of tree growth to winter cold. Further extending the scope of this PhD-thesis to global scales, litter decomposition rates were assessed across biomes (Manuscript 5). This study found a robust relationship between climate and decomposition rates, but it also demonstrated large within-biome variability on a local scale. These local scale differences might depend on habitat conditions that, in turn, could be modulated by climate change, which calls for a better exploration of indirect climate sensitivity. In conclusion, this PhD-thesis highlighted that multidisciplinary research can advance the understanding of ecological interactions in forest ecosystems under changing climate scenarios. In this PhD-project, a winter climate change experiment, where site-representative target trees were selected by means of dendroecology, contributed to a mechanistic understanding of winter cold sensitivity in forest growth dynamics. Dendroecological investigations then put the findings in a broader temporal and spatial context by describing local climate sensitivity of tree growth on different spatial scales. This thesis further shows that global generalizations about the relationship of climate and ecological processes in ecosystem models have to be critically reviewed for the need of local and regional adjustment because these processes might experience considerable regional- or local-scale variation. However, this thesis reports uniform sensitivity of ecological processes to altered winter soil temperature regimes across a large winter temperature gradient. Thus, upscaling from insights of previous winter climate change experiments to regional scales is encouraged.
Leaf-inhabiting fungi are a hyperdiverse group of microbiota found in all terrestrial habitats. Comparative studies targeting the drivers of endophytic fungal biodiversity are rare and identified multiple effectors, such as plant chemistry, climate and seasonal attributes. Our project aimed to study the pattern of the leaf-associated mycobiome of European beech (Fagus sylvatica) at altitudinally distinct sites to reveal diversity, composition and seasonal dynamics of fungal endophytes by a combination of metabarcoding, cultivation and subsequent ecological analyses. This thesis also intended to study the fungal relationship with biotic and abiotic factors: elevation, local site conditions, leaf biochemistry and leaf status. Metabarcoding and cultivation were applied for same leaf samples to trace both environmental drivers and method-dependent signals of the detected fungi. An experimental field site consisting of 100 (2-years old beech) trees was established called ‘beech phytometer’ system at two altitudes (517 and 975 m a.s.l.) in a German mountain forest. Beech trees were randomly selected from both sites as well as from neighboring beech trees. Ten trees from each site were chosen and 10 leaves per tree were sampled. Climatic and leaf biochemistry (Chlorophyll, flavonoid and nitrogen) data were seasonally (Autumn, Spring and Summer) investigated for two continuous years (Oct 2013 to Oct 2015) at these two elevations. In the first year (autumn, 2013) of the project (chapter 3.1), the leaf-inhabiting fungi of natural beech trees were investigated by using high-throughput sequencing (metabarcoding) at three altitudinally distinct sites (with timberline at 1381 m a.s.l.) in the German Alps. This paper focuses on a detailed description and evaluation of metabarcoding amplicon library preparation and a subsequent analytical workflow. Fungal diversity and community composition were compared as a function of different elevated sites and leaf status (i.e., vital or senescent). However, three investigation sites resulted in 969 OTUs (operational taxonomic units) from 820441 sequences. Taxonomic compositions (order) of beech fungi differed strongly among the three sites but were less distinct between the vital and the senescence leaves. Fungal community composition at valley site clearly differed from those of mountain and timberline where differences between mountain and timberline were less prominent. Vital and senescence leaf differed in fungal community structures indicating a strong dynamics of leaf fungi in autumn. Elevation and leaf status were found to be the main explaining factors, which affected the fungal richness and compositions. Another survey (Chapter 3.2) was conducted just after the establishment of the ‘beech phytometer’ trees in the same period (autumn 2013) where leaf mycobiome of the phytometer trees (trees originally came from Northern Germany and grown in nursery) were compared with the fungi of surrounding natural beech habitat at valley (517 m a.s.l.) and mountain site (975 m a.s.l.) in the same location “Untersberg”. Fungal diversity was lowest in the managed habitat in the nursery and was highest in natural habitat. Fungal diversity and compositions significantly associated the origin of the trees. Under natural conditions, the fungi were more diverse at lower altitudes than at higher altitudes. Additionally, leaf chlorophyll and flavonoid contents showed negative correlations with fungal richness in natural stands. In the second year (autumn 2014), another survey (chapter 3.3) was conducted on leaf endophytes of phytometer trees with metabarcoding and cultivation approaches to trace the environmental drivers and method-dependent indications. Metabarcoding resulted in 597 OTUs from 170480 curated ITS1 reads and cultivation revealed 70 OTUs from 438 culture-based Sanger sequences. Both approaches resulted in non-overlapping community compositions and pronounced differences in taxonomic classification and trophic stages. However, both methods revealed similar correlations of the fungal communities with local environmental conditions. Our results indicate undisputable advantages of metabarcoding over cultivation in terms of representation of the major functional guilds, rare taxa and diversity signals of leaf-inhabiting fungi. This stressed out the importance of cultivation for complementing sequence databases with good quality reference data and encouraged the use of both approaches in future microbial biodiversity assessment studies. Phytometer and natural trees were intensively investigated in this study (chapter 3.4) to assess the influence of site characteristics (altitudes, local microclimate), seasonality, leaf biochemistry and leaf age on fungal diversity and composition. In total, our analytical Illumina workflow resulted in 15703599 demultiplexed and ITS1 reads from 165 samples. Clustering at 97% similarity resulted in 1199 OTUs. Climatic parameters were significantly differed between valley and mountain on daily basis but were insignificantly differed on monthly basis. The compositional difference between phytometer and natural mycobiome was significant for combined data as well as for the seasonal data (Oct 2013-Oct 2014). We observed a strong seasonal turnover in phyllosphere fungi in both habitats over the two years of investigation, suggesting that the plant-fungal system not only responds to cyclic climatic conditions but depends as well on various parameters, e.g., geographic position, substrates age and surrounding vegetation. A side (chapter 3.5) study was done to see the connection between the foliar endophytes and foliar phenolic compounds of European aspen (Populus tremula) in the presence and absence of specialist beetles (Chrysomela tremula). A distinct pattern of the leaf endophytes was found to be associated with aspen genotype and chemotype, but this specificity disappeared in the presence of herbivorous beetles. This suggested that leaf endophytes responded to the herbivory in aspen. In general, the altitudinal difference is the most important explaining factor for fungal community differences, which shapes many dependent abiotic and biotic habitat factors. Regarding cost and time per sequence, metabarcoding is superior to cultivation approaches and offers surprisingly profound insights by yielding much more data, allowing to test at once multiple hypotheses in fungal ecology.