Doctoral Thesis
Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (2) (remove)
Language
- English (2)
Has Fulltext
- yes (2)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (2)
Keywords
- Dispersal (2) (remove)
Institute
Species persistence in the face of rapidly progressing environmental change requires adaptive responses that allow organisms to either cope with the novel conditions in their habitat or to follow their environmental niche in space. A poleward range shift due to global warming induced habitat loss in the south has been predicted for the lesser horseshoe bat, Rhinolophus hipposideros. Theoretical as well as numerous empirical studies link range expansion success to increased dispersal and reproduction rates due to spatial sorting and r-selection resulting from low population densities at the expansion front. R. hipposideros females however are highly philopatric and the species’ life history reflects a K- rather than an r-strategy, encompassing a long life span and limited individual annual reproductive output. I therefore investigated if adaptations in these traits determining range expansion success (dispersal and reproduction) can be observed in this bat species of high conservation concern. Genetic diversity presents a critical factor for adaptive responses to global change, both for range expansion and for coping with novel environmental conditions. I hence explored the genetic diversity levels of European R. hipposideros leading edge populations and their drivers for an assessment of these populations’ evolutionary potential and the development of conservation recommendations.
Comparing range expansion traits between an expanding R. hipposideros metapopulation in Germany and a non-expanding one in France revealed that range expansion was associated with an increase in juvenile survival and fecundity, and no decrease in adult survival. These results demonstrate than an increase in reproduction and growth rates is generally possible in R. hipposideros, indicating a potential adaptation (sensu lato) to range expansion. A positive correlation between adult and juvenile survival in the expanding metapopulation suggests higher resource acquisition in the expanding metapopulation, giving rise to the question if the observed demographic changes have a genetic basis or if they are rather induced by differences in environmental conditions between the two metapopulations. Long-term range expansion success requires adaptive evolutionary changes. The relative contribution of the former and that of undirected changes resulting e.g. from differences in resource availability therefore will have to be investigated in more detail in the future to allow predictions about range expansion dynamics in R. hipposideros.
The number of individuals within a radius of approximately 60 to 90 km around a population (as a measure of connectivity) was identified as the main positive driver of the studied populations’ genetic diversity. Overall genetic diversity levels in German R. hipposideros populations were found to be reduced compared to populations in France as a legacy of demographic bottlenecks resulting from severe population declines in the mid-20th century. This finding is alarming as future range expansion can be expected to entail a further decrease in genetic diversity. The resulting loss of genetic diversity can be expected to be particularly strong in R. hipposideros due to the detected dependence of genetic diversity on connectivity, because range expansion often results in small and patchy populations.
Protecting and ideally re-installing genetic diversity in R. hipposideros leading edge populations therefore presents a conservation goal of utmost importance. To achieve this endeavour, conservation efforts should target the protection of extensive networks of well-connected populations. Geographical concentration of individuals should be avoided and populations in key locations that connect clusters must be protected particularly well to prevent populations from becoming isolated. Continuous, regular monitoring of population trends is also important for a quick registration of disturbances or threats, and the subsequent rapid development of countermeasures to preclude further demographic declines.
The reduced levels of genetic diversity in the German metapopulation precluded a reliable quantification of dispersal rates due to the reduced power of discrimination between individuals. While ongoing re-colonization and the establishment of new maternity colonies provide evidence for increased dispersal in the expanding metapopulation, evaluating the expected range expansion velocity of R. hipposideros in relation to the estimated velocity of global warming induced habitat loss will require the confirmation of the existing preliminary dispersal data by employing more genetic markers.
In the current era of anthropogenic climate change is the long-term survival of all organisms dependent on their ability to respond to changing environmental conditions either by (1) phenotypic plasticity, which allows species to tolerate novel conditions, (2) genetic adaptation, or (3) dispersal to more suitable habitats. The third option, dispersal, allows individuals to escape unfavorable conditions, the colonization of new areas (resulting in range shifts), and affects patterns of local adaptation. It is a complex process serving different functions and involving a variety of underlying mechanisms, but its multi-causality though has been fully appreciated in recent years only. Thus, the aim of this doctoral thesis was to disentangle the relative importance of the multiple factors relevant to dispersal in the copper butterfly Lycaena tityrus, including the individual condition (e.g. morphology, physiology, behavior) and the environmental context (e.g. habitat quality, weather). L. tityrus is a currently northward expanding species, which makes it particularly interesting to investigate traits underlying dispersal. In the first experiment, the influence of weather and sex on movement patterns under natural conditions was investigated. Using the Metatron, a unique experimental platform consisting of interconnected habitat patches, the second experiment aimed to examine the influence of environmental factors (resources, sun) on emigration propensity in experimental metapopulations. Human-induced global change (e.g. climate change, agricultural intensification) poses a substantial challenge to many herbivores due to a reduced availability or quality of feeding resources. Therefore, in the third experiment, the impact of larval and adult food stress on traits related to dispersal ability was investigated. Additionally, the effect of different ambient temperatures was tested. In the fourth experiment, core (Germany) and recently established edge (Estonia) populations were compared in order to explore variation in dispersal ability and life history traits indicative of local adaptation. Dispersal is often related to flight performance, and morphological and physiological traits, which was investigated in experiments 2-4. Butterflies were additionally subjected to behavioral experiments testing for the individual’s exploratory behavior (experiments 3 and 4).
Males and females differed substantially in morphology, with males showing traits typically associated with a better flight performance, which most likely result from selection on males for an increased flight ability to succeed in aerial combats with rivalling males and competition for females. This pattern could be verified by mobility measures under natural conditions and flight performance tests. Interestingly, although females showed traits associated with diminished flight performance, they had a higher emigration propensity than males (though in a context dependent manner). Reasons might be the capability of single mated females to found new populations, to spread their eggs over a wide range or to escape male harassment. Conditions indicative of poor habitat quality such as shade and a lack of resources promoted emigration propensity. The environmental context also affected condition and flight performance. The presence of resources increased the butterflies’ condition and flight performance. Larval and adult food stress in turn diminished flight performance, despite some reallocation of somatic resources in favor of dispersal-related traits. These detrimental effects seem to be mainly caused by reductions in body mass and storage reserves. A similar pattern was found for exploratory behavior. Furthermore, higher temperatures increased flight performance and mobility in the field, demonstrating the strong dependence of flight, and thus likely dispersal, on environmental conditions. Flight performance and exploratory behavior were positively correlated, probably indicating the existence of a dispersal syndrome. The population comparison revealed several differences between edge and core populations indicative of local adaptation and an enhanced dispersal ability in edge populations. For instance, edge populations were characterized by shorter development times, smaller size, and a higher sensitivity to high temperatures, which seem to reflect adaptations to the cooler Estonian climate and a shorter vegetation period. Moreover, Estonian individuals had an enhanced exploratory behavior, which can be advantageous in all steps of the dispersal process and may have facilitated the current range expansion.
In summary, these findings may have important implications for dispersal in natural environments, which should be considered when trying to forecast future species distributions. First, dispersal in this butterfly seems to be a highly plastic, context-dependent trait triggered largely by habitat quality rather than by individual condition. This suggests that dispersal in L. tityrus is not random, but an active process. Second, fast development and an enhanced exploratory behavior seem to facilitate the current range expansion. But third, while deteriorating habitat conditions are expected to promote dispersal, they may at the same time impair flight ability (as well as exploratory
behavior) and thereby likely dispersal rates. For a complete understanding of a complex process such as dispersal, further research is required.