Doctoral Thesis
Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (2) (remove)
Language
- English (2)
Has Fulltext
- yes (2)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (2)
Keywords
- Bicyclus anynana (2) (remove)
Institute
In holometabolic insects, senescence starts at sexual maturation and condition diminishes with age. Young virgin males should gain the highest mating success. Although sperm quality and quantity typically decreases with age, older males have been shown to have a higher mating success in a variety of insect taxa. Life-history theory predicts an increased aggressive and persistent courtship behaviour, due to a decrease of the residual reproductive value and thus, the opportunity for future reproduction. In the butterfly Bicyclus anynana, older males gain up to a 4x higher mating success despite a poorer condition, compared to younger males. As older males were found to court more often and for longer time bouts,suggesting a higher intrinsic motivation, there is evidence for the residual reproductive value hypothesis. On the other hand, an age-specific variation of male sex pheromones may provide females with information, being helpful to chose specific males. The latter could be males which have proven a high fitness in terms of survival, thus essentially reflecting a “good genes" hypothesis. This doctoral thesis investigated the reasons underlying old male mating advantage in B. anynana. The first study tested whether old male mating advantage prevails, even if females were unable to distinguish between older and younger males. The results were backed up by examining female rejection rates, male courtship frequency, courtship duration, time to copulation and mating duration. Older males had a significantly higher mating success compared to younger ones regardless of differences in pheromone blends or the females ability to smell. Older males courted more often and longer. The results support the residual reproductive value hypothesis. Study 2 investigated post-copulatory sexual selection in B. anynana. Females were double-mated, allowing for sperm competition and cryptic mate choice. Older males had a higher paternity success than younger ones, when the former were the last mating partner. The paternity success was balanced across age classes when older males were the first mating partner. Older males transferred larger spermatophores with higher numbers of eupyrene sperm than younger males. B. anynana does not exhibit cryptic mate choice and last-male precedence is the most probable fertilization pattern. The higher proportion of offspring sired by older males is due to significantly increased numbers of fertile sperm compared to younger males. The latter are clearly disadvantaged, as the higher sperm numbers provided by older males counteract the benefits of last-male precedence. Study 3 explored determinants of mating success in B. anynana. Successful males had longer wings, a heavier thorax, a lighter abdomen, a higher fat content, and higher phenoloxidase expression levels. Mating success seemed to be directly linked to proxies of flight performance. Successful males showed a better flight performance, in turn increasing mating success. As energy reserves are of crucial importance for flight manoeuvres, they may play a significant role in male mating success. Study 4 tested the effects of male age and mating number on spermatophore mass, sperm number, male oxidative status, and reproductive success by manipulating age and mating frequency in male B. anynana. Spermatophore mass and sperm numbers increased significantly with age, while antioxidant defences and oxidative damage declined. Female fecundity and egg-hatching success was highest when being mated with young virgin males. Antioxidant defences decreased with age, being a possible reason for the negatively affected reproductive success in females. Ejaculate quality diminished with age and mating number, despite larger spermatophores and higher sperm numbers being found in older males. Therefore, spermatophore size and sperm numbers can not be considered as reliable proxies of male condition. The final study proofed whether male sex pheromone comprise honest signals and which traits might be associated with increased pheromone titres. Pheromone titres were analysed among successful and unsuccessful males when being mated with either a control or a scent-blocked female. Both groups did not differ in pheromone levels. Successful males had significantly higher numbers of eupyrene sperm. No correlation between male pheromones and any investigated trait was found, suggesting that pheromone titres do not provide reliable information on male quality. Nothing indicates that male sex pheromones in B. anynana play a decisive role in female mate choice. Successful males generally have a better body condition, resulting in a more vigorous courtship behaviour and higher sperm numbers. Hence, variation in body condition rather than pheromone titres is more likely to determine male mating success. Mating decisions are primarily driven by male behaviour. The results suggest that old male mating advantage arises from sexual conflict.
The impact of inbreeding under different environmental conditions and of artificial selection on cold tolerance was investigated in laboratory populations of the tropical butterfly Bicyclus anynana. The investigation focused on (1) the effects of inbreeding on several fitness-related traits and whether inbred individuals are more susceptible to stress, (2) interactions between inbreeding, genetic adaptation to cold stress and environmental conditions, (3) the effects of artificial selection and inbreeding in the adult stage in other developmental stages, and (4) the effect of inbreeding depression on the heat shock response. Environmental conditions are not constant over time; consequently organisms have to deal with environmental changes. Besides naturally fluctuating conditions, human-induced climate change may increase temperature changes as well as the severity of heat or cold waves. Temperature-stress resistance describes an organism’s ability to cope with stressful temperatures. Enhanced resistance to temperature stress can be reached by phenotypic plasticity or genetic adaptation. Plastic organisms are able to react fast to changing environmental conditions, whereas genetic adaptation is more important for long-term adaptation. Natural habitats may also be affected by human impact, causing habitat loss or fragmentation and changes in population structure. A decrease in the population size may result in inbreeding and inbreeding depression (ID). Consequences of inbreeding are well documented, and inbred individuals are predicted to be more sensitive to environmental stress than outbred individuals. The long term persistence of species and populations depends on their ability to adapt to novel conditions which in turn depends on genetic diversity. Therefore, studies of temperature resistance and its evolution in relation to inbreeding are very important. First a higher susceptibility of inbred individuals to environmental stress was determined in different populations of B. anynana. Inbreeding depression was revealed for several fitness-related traits, but not for immunity traits or heat tolerance. Temperature affected most traits, revealing the importance of temperature on ectotherms; just two hours of thermal stress affected important reproductive, life-history and immunity traits already. Importantly though, no evidence were found that inbred individuals are more susceptible to stressful temperatures than outbred individuals. Genetic adaptation and phenotypic plasticity can interact with one another, resulting in genotype-environmental interactions (G x E). The hypotheses tested here were that some genotypes are more plastic than others and that lines with increased cold stress resistance are less plastic with regard to cold resistance than control lines. To induce plastic responses the exposed lines differed in cold tolerance and inbreeding to different temperatures as well as different feeding regimes and measured fitness-related traits. Several interactions were detected in which a selection regime was involved, but these interactions did not show a clear overall pattern. In summary though, findings were that marginal impacts of directional selection and inbreeding on plastic responses and suggest that, at least for my study organism, the genetic architecture of fitness-related traits is not connected with the architecture of plastic responses. The next investigation concerned with the manifestation of genetic adaptation to produce one specific phenotype across development stages and possible trade-offs. The assumption tested was that there is a genetic link between different developmental stages to produce one definite phenotype by imposing selection in the adult stage only. Lines selected for increased cold resistance in the adult stage were used and increased cold resistance throughout all developmental stages was expected. However, higher cold resistance was found only in the adult stage and not in developmental stages. This could be either the result of a resource allocation trade-off between different stages or that there is no cold resistance phenotype. Thus, if selection takes place in the adult stage it does not affect the others. In the last experiment investigation was directed to determine whether there are negative inbreeding effects on the heat shock protein (HSP) response. Under stressful conditions, organisms produce the HSPs and they act as chaperons required for refolding and repairing of stress degraded proteins. Testing was oriented to find if inbreeding as a genetic stressor´ provokes a higher HSP expression and if there is evidence for higher temperature stress susceptibility on inbred individuals. Findings indeed showed a stronger HSP up-regulation in control compared to inbred lines with a negative inbreeding impact occurrence, which may causally underlie inbreeding depression.