Refine
Document Type
- Doctoral Thesis (2)
Language
- English (2) (remove)
Has Fulltext
- yes (2)
Is part of the Bibliography
- no (2)
Keywords
- Vogelzug (2) (remove)
Institute
Analysis of partial migration strategies of Central European raptors based on ring re-encounter data
(2018)
The phenomenon of partial migration in birds in
which some individuals of a population are migratory while others stay in the breeding area is of increasing scientific interest. The strategies of partial migratory raptors from Central Europe are, however, unclear for most species. We analysed ring re-encounter data of Common Kestrels Falco tinnunculus, Eurasian Sparrowhawks Accipter nisus and Common Buzzards Buteo buteo ringed in Germany in terms of distances and directions between ringing and re-encounter sites. We investigated possible differences between sexes and age classes, as well as effects of ringing region, seasonal weather (in the form of North Atlantic Oscillation indices) and long-term temporal changes (including climate change) on migratory strategies by means of generalized linear models. We found that migration is mostly conducted by juveniles, although migratory adults were also found. In general, males tend to migrate less than females and juveniles less than adults.
Kestrels showed differences between age classes and sexes and they responded to weather in summer and autumn. The migration activities of Kestrels decreased over years. Sparrowhawks from different regions showed no differences in migration activity and no responses to long-term temporal changes. They did not respond to seasonal weather either. Buzzards showed strong responses to winter weather (‘winter escapes’) predominantly in highland regions, and a reduction of migratory intensity probably due to global warming.
The explanatory power of ringing data, however, is limited by low re-encounter rates and temporal and spatial heterogeneity in re-encounter probability. Spatial heterogeneity mainly depends on the distribution of observers as well as on their willingness to report a re-encountered ring to the corresponding ringing scheme. We analyzed a data set of ringing and re-encounter data of Kestrels, Buzzards and Sparrowhawks provided by the EURING Data Bank. We calculated monthly re-encounter rates across Europe and, for different time periods, we predicted re-encounters for individuals of these species ringed in Germany, on the assumption that re-encounter probabilities are evenly distributed at the highest value observed within the respective home ranges. Subsequently, we tested for correlation between re-encounter rates and human population density. The number of predicted re-encounters exceed the observed by 50-300 %. We found differences between monthly re-encounter rates and between different prediction periods. Distances (between ringing and re-encounter sites) differ significantly between observations and predicted re-encounters, with higher distances in predictions. Correlation between re-encounter rates and human population density is significant, but correlation coefficients are low (ρ = 0.291-0.511). Correcting for observer heterogeneity can help to analyze ring re-encounter data e.g. in terms of dispersal and migration. However, a comprehensive data collection and a digitalization of possible prior data records by the respective ringing schemes may allow advances in this method even further.
Deflected by the barrier function of topographical structures such as high mountain ranges, open water bodies or desert, migrating birds concentrate at certain points or corridors referred to as ‘bottlenecks’. An area like this was discovered at Mount Besh Barmag (Azerbaijan) in autumn 2007, but the data gathered during a four-week survey was insufficient to do more than hint at the existence of a major bird migration bottleneck. Therefore, a comprehensive bird migration study was conducted to analyse the magnitude of this potential bottleneck site. The study covers the periods from August to mid-November 2011 and from March to the end of May 2012 and includes daily counts at three observation points focusing on three different migrant types: passerine, waterbirds and soaring birds. In addition, a sound recorder with an omnidirectional microphone collected bird migration calls by both day and night. In total, 278 bird species were observed in an estimated passage of 1,239,369–1,514,267 diurnally migrating individuals in autumn 2011 and 646,733–817,183 individuals in spring 2012. Fifteen species passed through the study area in numbers exceeding 1% of their world populations and 34 species in more than 1% of their flyway populations in at least one of the observation periods. 84% of the observed migrating birds in autumn 2011 and 95% of them in spring 2012 passed through at heights below 50 m above ground exposing them imminently to the danger of collision with obstacles. In the analysis of nocturnal sound recordings, 119 bird species were identified of which 106 were expected to occur as migrants, and calculated estimates revealed the occurrence of 108,986 calls in autumn 2011 and 33,348 calls in spring 2012. The volume of diurnal bird migration emerging from the data with respect to species number and number of individuals is certainly a strong indication of the existence of a major bird migration bottleneck at Besh Barmag. On account of methodological constraints, the high number of night flight calls can only hint at a nocturnal bird migration bottleneck and confirmatory research aided by visual methods (radar, thermal imaging) is necessary to back up the acoustic results. The Besh Barmag bottleneck offers a great opportunity to establish a standardised long-term monitoring programme to investigate avian population dynamics in the vast and little known Eurasian landmass. Acoustic-based monitoring might be a cost-effective method, but it is limited to a few vocally prolific species only. The aim should rather be the establishment of a bird observatory as already successfully installed in a number of European bird migration bottlenecks.